Skip to main content

Blog / News Break

How to Get Out of a Default Judgment When You Were Sued in the Wrong County

A debt buyer sued Brian Parker's client in the wrong county twice and garnished her wages twice. How to set aside a default, and what changed in 2026.

Consumer defense attorney Brian ParkerBrian Parker · 9 min read

Two years ago, Brian Parker's client found out she had been sued only when her employer started sending her garnishment notices. A debt buyer had sued her in the wrong court, in the wrong county, and won a default judgment she never saw. Brian got it set aside with her state ID and her lease.

Now the same debt buyer has done it again. Same client, wrong county again, another default, another garnishment at work. In the video below, Brian explains how to get out of a default judgment, whether it was your fault or not, and why the second time is going to cost the collector.

Key Takeaways

  • There are three default clocks: the default, the default judgment, and the void judgment. Know which one you are on.
  • If you were never served, the judgment is void. But since the Supreme Court's 2026 Coney Island decision, you must still move within a reasonable time.
  • A debt collector must sue you where you live or where you signed the contract. Suing in the wrong county can support an FDCPA claim.
  • Act in the first 72 hours: get the garnishment papers, pull the court file, and put the collector on written notice.

The best way out is never getting in

Before a default, you get a lawsuit in the mail. Brian's RACE framework starts there:

  • R: Read the complaint and the summons. The summons tells you how many days you have to answer, and it says you will be defaulted if you do not. Brian files about five days before the deadline, because weird things happen.
  • A: Answer with a responsive pleading. Brian has been recommending that November 9 video to a lot of people.
  • C: Counter affidavit, attached to your answer. A plain answer that never says you dispute the debt gets a plain response when you try to settle.
  • E: Everything else, such as consent orders against the company suing you.

But sometimes you get defaulted through no fault of your own. That is this case.

Defaulted twice at the wrong address

The first time, the client told Brian she had been sued in the wrong court and the wrong county. She learned about it only when her workplace started sending her garnishment notices. Brian says that when you learn about a default that way, you have a strong motion to set aside.

He had her sign an affidavit: wrong person, wrong court, wrong county. He showed the collector her state ID and proof that she did not live in the county where she was sued. Brian says that case was done in minutes. Her name is unusual, and she is not a Junior or a Senior, so a mix-up was hard to explain.

Two years later, the same plaintiff sued her in the wrong county again. Brian won't name it, except to say it goes by three initials. Again she learned about it from a garnishment notice at work, after assuring her employer the first time that the debt was not hers.

Why does the second time matter? Under the FDCPA, a collector can raise the bona fide error defense: the mistake was unintentional, and it happened despite reasonable procedures. Brian says that may cover the first time. Computers, things fall through the cracks. But the second time came after Brian put the collector on notice of her correct address. "They're going to pay," he says.

He also points out the irony. Collectors find you perfectly well when they want to garnish you. They just cannot seem to find you when it is time to serve you.

A diagram titled defaulted twice at the wrong address. Two rows tell the client's story. The first time: sued in the wrong county, a default judgment she never saw, learning about it from a garnishment at work, and a set aside using her state ID and lease. Two years later, same plaintiff: sued in the wrong county again, another default, another garnishment notice, and a motion to set aside plus an FDCPA 1692i claim. A note says Brian believes the bona fide error defense may cover a first mistake, but after notice it does not cover the second. Below, three cards ask which clock you are on: the default, before judgment and the easiest to undo; the default judgment, for excusable neglect or mistake, where you must move fast; and the void judgment, where you were never served so the court had no jurisdiction, which must still be challenged within a reasonable time. A gold panel cites Coney Island Auto Parts v. Burton, U.S. Supreme Court, 2026: even a void judgment must be challenged within a reasonable time.

Which clock are you on?

Brian sorts defaults into three kinds. His three clocks article covers them by state.

  1. The default before judgment. In many states, a default comes first and turns into a default judgment later, for example after 21 days. A default is easier to undo than a default judgment.
  2. The default judgment, for excusable neglect or mistake. Whoops: it was not my fault, my attorney missed it, my sister hid the papers. You need a reason the court should forgive the miss, and a meritorious defense.
  3. The void judgment. If you were never served, the court never got jurisdiction over you. This is the clock Brian's client is on, and the one he hears about most. You usually do not need the two-part argument, because the court had no power over you in the first place.

The Supreme Court's 2026 change

It used to be that a void judgment could be attacked at any time. Find out six years later, go to court, and say the court never had jurisdiction.

In Coney Island Auto Parts v. Burton (opens in a new tab), decided January 20, 2026, the Supreme Court said no. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(4), a motion to set aside a void judgment still has to be made within a reasonable time. The Court refused to treat void judgments as exempt. Brian says the party in that case waited about six years, after getting notices.

Brian says most states follow the federal rule, and Florida in particular expects you to move speedily. "Reasonable" is flexible. If you never knew about the lawsuit and found out only when your wages were garnished, waiting until then is reasonable. But once you know, the window starts to close. The longest Brian has gone is a default three years old. After a while, even courts stop caring.

Every one of Brian's motions to set aside ends the same way: "Your Honor, all I want is my day in court."

The first 72 hours

Most people who were never served find out the hard way: a credit report, or more often a garnishment at work or at the bank. Then they have to explain to a whole set of third parties that they are not deadbeats.

  1. Get the garnishment paperwork from your employer or bank. Expect a cold response. Brian says they face sanctions if they do not move fast on a garnishment. Get the papers anyway, because they tell you how many days you have to object. In Michigan, he says, you have 14 days to object and stop the bank from paying the law firm.
  2. Pull the whole court file. A default file is thin, because the case went fast, so it will not cost much. It is free discovery. Look for what they claimed: that you were served on a date you were out of town, or in a county you did not live in.
  3. Write down the dates and make a chronology. If they say you were served on the 31st and you were visiting your sister in another state, show the ticket.
  4. Gather proof of where you actually lived. Brian asks every client for a mortgage or lease for the address at the time.
  5. Put the collector and its law firm on written notice, with your state ID and proof of address. Brian's letter says, in effect: take care of this today, because tomorrow you won't like it.
  6. Sign a counter affidavit. Brian often sends it to the plaintiff's attorney before he files the motion: deal with me now, or pay me later. More on counter affidavits.
  7. Object to the garnishment right away. An objection does not kill the judgment, but it is a stepping stone. Brian says Michigan's objection form is MC 49, and your state court website will have its own.
  8. Give the collector one chance to fix it before you file.
  9. If they blow you off, file the motion to set aside.
  10. Ask for your money back. If the judgment is set aside, they have probably already taken money through the garnishment. Request it in writing, by certified mail with return receipt, and keep the receipts.

Turning the tables

Once the default is set aside, Brian looks at claims against the collector.

Wrong venue. Under 15 U.S.C. 1692i (opens in a new tab), a debt collector suing on a consumer debt must file in the judicial district where you live or where you signed the contract. Brian's client lived and worked in one county and was sued in another, twice.

The one-year clock. FDCPA claims must be filed within one year (15 U.S.C. 1692k (opens in a new tab)), so be aware of it.

Credit reporting. If the collector puts the account on your credit report, send a dispute letter. Brian says that if they still do not take it off, you may have a claim under the Fair Credit Reporting Act, with a two-year statute of limitations, and an impermissible purpose claim. Before he files, he sends a permissible purpose letter asking why they are on the client's credit and what proof they have that they own the debt. He says nobody has answered that question in more than 30 years.

Unfair means. Brian also points to 15 U.S.C. 1692e and 1692f. Getting a judgment without real service and then using it to take someone's wages can be unfair. Doing it a second time after you were handed the consumer's correct address is worse.

Who you can sue. The debt buyer, the collection agency, and the collection law firm. Brian sues the law firm in maybe one case out of ten. Process servers are generally exempt under the FDCPA, but Brian says some collectors now own process serving companies. A server who pushes you to call the collector, or reads your lawsuit, may lose that protection, he says.

Not federal court as an appeal. Some people with a state default judgment go to federal court to overturn it. Under the Rooker-Feldman doctrine, only the U.S. Supreme Court can review state court judgments. Brian says the doctrine keeps getting weaker, but you generally cannot use federal court as an appeal from state court.

The void judgment is the best default to have, if there is such a thing. But even it has a clock now. If a garnishment is how you learned you were sued, start today. ParkerGPT drafts the motion to set aside and the counter affidavit from your court file.

Garnished for a judgment you never saw? ParkerGPT drafts the motion to set aside, the counter affidavit, and the notice letter to the collector.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I set aside a default judgment if I was never served?
Yes. If you were never properly served, the court never got jurisdiction over you, and the judgment is void. Brian Parker calls this the strongest of the three default clocks, because you usually do not need the two-part argument a missed deadline requires. But you still have to move within a reasonable time once you learn about it.
Is there a time limit to challenge a void judgment?
Yes, under the federal rule. In Coney Island Auto Parts v. Burton (2026), the U.S. Supreme Court held that a Rule 60(b)(4) motion to vacate a void judgment must be made within a reasonable time. Brian Parker says most states follow the federal rule. Learning about the judgment from a garnishment and acting fast is reasonable. Waiting years is not.
Can a debt collector sue me in a different county?
Under the FDCPA, 15 U.S.C. 1692i, a debt collector suing on a consumer debt must file where you live or where you signed the contract. Brian Parker's client lived and worked in one county and was sued in another, twice. That can support an FDCPA claim, which has a one-year statute of limitations.
What is the bona fide error defense under the FDCPA?
It lets a debt collector avoid liability if it shows the violation was unintentional and happened despite reasonable procedures to prevent it. Brian Parker says it may cover a first mistake, such as suing at a wrong address. Once you put the collector on notice of your correct address and it does it again, he says it has no real defense.
What should I do first after a garnishment for a judgment I never knew about?
Move in the first 72 hours. Get the garnishment paperwork from your employer or bank, because objection windows can be short. Pull the whole court file, which is usually thin in a default case. Build a chronology, gather proof of where you lived, and put the collector and its law firm on written notice with that proof.
Consumer defense attorney Brian Parker

About the author

Brian Parker

I have over 30 years of experience defending consumers against debt collection lawsuits and have seen every tactic, threat, and pressure play that collectors use. Through KillDebt and ParkerGPT, I have systematized the proven defense strategies that actually work - so consumers can respond from a position of knowledge, not fear. My approach focuses on aggressive legal defense based on documented case success rather than false hope that leads to default judgments.

All articles